| PWA Women's Title | ||||||
| Name | Date won | Days | Location | Notes | Held | |
| Trish Stratus | 11/18/01 | 78 | Greensboro, NC | This was a six way match, also involving Lita, Jacqueline, Ivory, Molly Holly, and Jazz. | 1 | |
| Jazz | 2/4/02 | 98 | Las Vegas, NV | 1 | ||
| Trish Stratus | 5/13/02 | 41 | Toronto, ON | 2 | ||
| Jennifer Shamrock | 6/23/02 | 91 | Columbus, OH | 1 | ||
| Trish Stratus | 9/22/02 | 56 | Los Angeles, CA | 3 | ||
| Victoria | 11/17/02 | 133 | New York, NY | This was a hardcore match. | 1 | |
| Trish Stratus | 3/30/03 | 28 | Seattle, WA | This was a triple–threat match also involving Jazz. | 4 | |
| Jennifer Shamrock | 4/27/03 | 64 | Worcester, MA | 2 | ||
| Gail Kim | 6/30/03 | 28 | Buffalo, NY | This was a seven-woman battle royal, also involving Ivory, Victoria, Molly Holly, Trish Stratus and Jacqueline. | 1 | |
| Trish Stratus | 7/28/03 | 210 | Colorado Springs, CO | 5 | ||
| Victoria | 2/23/04 | 111 | Omaha, NE | This was a fatal four-way elimination match, also involving Lita and Jazz. | 2 | |
| Trish Stratus | 6/13/04 | 176 | Columbus, OH | This was a fatal four-way match also involving Lita and Gail Kim. | 6 | |
| Lita | 12/6/04 | 34 | Charlotte, NC | This was contested in the main event of Raw. With the win, Lita became the first woman to win the title two times in the main event. | 2 | |
| Trish Stratus | 1/9/05 | 448 | San Juan, Puerto Rico | 7 | ||
| Mickie James | 4/2/06 | 134 | Rosemont, IL | 1 | ||
| Lita | 8/14/06 | 34 | Charlottesville, VA | 3 | ||
| Trish Stratus | 9/17/06 | 1 | Toronto, ON | 8 | ||
| Vacated | 9/18/06 | — | Montreal, QC | Title vacated due to Stratus' retirement. | — | |
| Lita | 11/5/06 | 21 | Cincinnati, OH | This was a Lumberjack match. Lita defeated Mickie James in a tournament final. | 4 | |
| Mickie James | 11/26/06 | 85 | Philadelphia, PA | 2 | ||
| Jennifer Shamrock | 2/19/07 | 64 | Bakersfield, CA | 3 | ||
| Mickie James | 4/24/07 | 0 | Paris, France | This was a triple–threat match also involving Victoria. | 3 | |
| Jennifer Shamrock | 4/24/07 | 61 | Paris, France | Melina was awarded an immediate rematch because Mickie pinned Victoria who was not the champion. | 4 | |
| Candice Michelle | 6/24/07 | 105 | Houston, TX | 1 | ||
| Beth Phoenix | 10/7/07 | 190 | Rosemont, IL | 1 | ||
| Mickie James | 4/14/08 | 125 | London, England | 4 | ||
| Michelle McCool | 7/20/08 | 155 | Uniondale, NY | 1 | ||
| Maryse | 12/22/08 | 218 | Toronto, ON | 1 | ||
| Mickie James | 7/26/09 | 78 | Philadelphia, PA | 5 | ||
| Jillian Hall | 10/12/09 | 0 | Indianapolis, IN | 1 | ||
| Melina | 10/12/09 | 84 | Indianapolis, IN | 1 | ||
| Vacated | 1/4/10 | — | Dayton, OH | Vacated the title after Melina sustained a torn anterior cruciate ligament, which sidelined her from in-ring competition. | — | |
| Maryse | 2/22/10 | 49 | Indianapolis, IN | Defeated Gail Kim in a tournament final. | 2 | |
| Eve Torres | 4/12/10 | 69 | London, England | 1 | ||
| Alicia Fox | 6/20/10 | 56 | Uniondale, NY | This was a fatal four–way match also involving Gail Kim and Maryse. | 1 | |
| Melina | 8/15/10 | 35 | Los Angeles, CA | 1 | ||
| Michelle McCool | 9/19/10 | 63 | Rosemont, IL | 2 | ||
| Natalya | 11/21/10 | 70 | Miami, FL | This was a handicap match also involving Layla as Michelle McCool's tag team partner. | 1 | |
| Eve Torres | 1/30/11 | 71 | Boston, MA | This was a fatal four–way match also involving Layla and Michelle McCool. | 2 | |
| Brie Bella | 4/11/11 | 70 | Bridgeport, CT | 1 | ||
| Kelly Kelly | 6/20/11 | 104 | Baltimore, MD | 1 | ||
| Beth Phoenix | 10/2/11 | 204 | New Orleans, LA | 1 | ||
| Nikki Bella | 4/23/12 | 6 | Detroit, MI | 1 | ||
| Layla | 4/29/12 | 140 | Rosemont, IL | Layla pinned Brie Bella to win the title from Nikki after the twins switched places during the match while the referee was distracted. | 1 | |
| Eve Torres | 9/16/12 | 120 | Boston, MA | 3 | ||
| Kaitlyn | 1/14/13 | 104+ | Houston, TX | If Eve had been counted out or disqualified, she would have lost the title. | 1 | |